KalshiSpy vs PillarLab

What KalshiSpy does

Paid dashboard for Kalshi, not Polymarket. It follows a roster of 32 Kalshi accounts it ranks as top traders, groups their open positions by market and shows which side each holds, how much, and how many of them agree, with alerts and a link to the market on kalshi.com. You place every trade yourself. A free ranking, a snapshot and an archive of settled wins are public. Premium is listed at $90 a month and shown at $63 during a 48-hour countdown, an AI and API plan costs more, and there is a one-time Lifetime plan; there is no trial and no refund.

• Roster of 32 Kalshi accounts with positive lifetime realized profit, ranked by that profit
• Open positions grouped by market, with each trader's side, size, price and profit in that category
• Consensus share for each market and a link straight to it on kalshi.com
• Alerts on each market's newest position and on markets where 3+ ranked traders hold, 70% or more on one side
• Free public ranking, a snapshot of how many top-10 traders are in each live market, and a settled-wins archive

• The figures for each named trader check out; the “top” in top traders does not. Kalshi's public profile data gave @BWmarkets $818,135 of profit across 293 markets on Nov 9, 2026, as KalshiSpy says, and the +9.7% ROI is that profit divided by dollars traded. But KalshiSpy's page says @BWmarkets leads its ranking, while Kalshi's own all-time profit leaderboard put the same account 79th that day, with 78 accounts ahead of it and the leader on $7.7 million. The roster is a selection, and the FAQ describes how it is chosen only as “exclusive data” and a proprietary method. Some of its records are short: @devex, ranked 7th, joined Kalshi in June 2026 and has traded 15 markets.
• The public record is wins only, and the site says so in places. The archive lists 6,153 settled markets where roster traders held the winning side, with $22.6 million of net realized profit on those wins; the losing side of the same traders' books is not shown, so the number says nothing about how often following them pays. About a third of the wins are crypto, and the newest pages are mostly BTC 15-minute markets won by @szg.szg for a few hundred dollars each, an account whose lifetime ROI the site shows as +0.2%. The home page counts the record from Jan 2025, while the archive page says its 6,152 wins run from Nov 8, 2025. The site's comparison with Polymarket lists a “cherry-picked winner” with “losers hidden” among Polymarket's faults, which sits oddly beside a wins-only archive.
• Following positions on Kalshi is ordinary trading, and nothing here touches your account. What it adds is the market-by-market grouping, which Kalshi's one-profile-at-a-time pages do not offer. A follower still enters after the roster has, at whatever price is left, and some of these accounts are market makers or high-volume traders whose positions are not bets in the usual sense.